Determination of the ROI of online training is a hot topic today. In this article, I outline a popular ROI methodology (using Kirkpatrick’s model of evaluation), and 5 tips that you can use to maximize ROI in corporate training.
Maximize The ROI Of Online Training In 5 Ways
Let me begin with a few basic definitions related to ROI of online training first:
What Is Return On Investment (ROI) In Corporate Training?
In general terms, Return on Investment (ROI) is the gain divided by the cost. In the same way, ROI in corporate training is the gain on account of the impact of the training divided by the training cost.
As suggested by Keri Bennington of UNC Kenan-Flager Business School in a report,
“ROI measures should be related to performance after the L&D experience and, according to some, tied to a dollar figure. For example, time saved or increased output (or both) as a result of improved performance following participation in a development program can then be compared to a dollar figure”.
To establish a positive ROI, the training initiative should be able to show a demonstrable gain more than the investment made. While, the definition of ROI in corporate training sounds simple enough, measuring this is can be a tall order.
Let me begin with the easier bit, that is determining the costs:
Costs Of Online Training Would Typically Include
- The cost of eLearning development
- The time and effort clocked by the Subject Matter Experts
- The time and effort clocked by the team coordinating the eLearning development
- The infrastructure and associated support costs
- Optional costs in order to update the training
The value is the demonstrable gain for the learners and the organization. This is difficult to measure.
At EI Design, we have been working with the L&D teams across the world for over 16 years now. During this journey, we have used several approaches that you can implement to maximize the ROI of online training. Before outlining these approaches, let us look at one of the popular ROI methodologies.
Which ROI Methodology Can Be Used?
Most of us are familiar with the Kirkpatrick’s model of evaluation. In today’s context, adding Phillips’ ROI calculation as the fifth level makes this framework more useful and relevant.
This is how this combination would work:
- After establishing the gain through the 4 levels of Kirkpatrick’s model of evaluation, we can monetize it (that is, associate a monetary value to it).
- When we compare this with the eLearning development and the associated costs, we can assess if there is a positive or negative ROI of online training.
To give you a sense of how it can be practically used, let me outline the approaches we, at EI Design, typically adopt to help our customers determine the ROI of their online training:
Level 1: Reaction
This level relates to the learner’s reaction and satisfaction. To obtain the learner’s feedback, we add surveys in the eLearning course. Today, we have the flexibility to also add other aspects that indicate a learner’s reaction by asking them if they “like the course” or would they “recommend the course”.
Level 2: Learning
The classic approach to measuring what the learners learned (validate against the expected takeaways) is through summative assessments (at the end of the course).
Level 3: Application (Performance Gain Or Behavioral changes)
This crucial aspect is certainly more difficult to measure. However, going back to the pointers collated during the Training Needs Analysis (TNA) provides the cues to assess if there has been a clear and demonstrable gain or not. This gain should be directly attributable to the online training.
The TNA would typically reflect the following aspects:
- Need to acquire a new skill
- Gap in the current skills
- Measures to further improve the proficiency (for instance, from basic to advanced level of mastery)
A few notable aspects:
- We need to drill down through the TNA pointers to establish what desirable change or gain should be established. This would certainly have some tangible and some intangible gains. Both should be captured.
- Then, we need to ascertain, how this gain/change will be measured (over a stipulated period).
- We also need to identify if we need to add Performance Support Tools or learning aids to support the formal training (to help learners apply their learning and practice to move to the desired levels of proficiency or mastery).
Level 4: Business Impact
As an extension to the exercise for Level 2 and 3, we now need to identify how will the desired business impact be measured.
Some of the parameters we use include:
- Increased productivity
- Improved quality
- Lower review time
- Reduction in rework
- Contribution at next level (that has a higher value)
Level 5: ROI
When you convert the business impact to a monetary value, you can use it to compare against the costs incurred and arrive at the ROI of online training.
What Are The Tips That Can Be Used To Maximize The ROI?
Now, I will share 5 tips that you can use to maximize the ROI of online training. You will note that each of these tips influences different levels of the Kirkpatrick’s model of evaluation.
These measures are easy to implement and will also enable you to assess the impact of each measure from Level 1 to Level 4 (of the Kirkpatrick model).
The entire exercise begins with the TNA where the current and desired competency mapping is done, and the expected learning gains or outcomes are identified.
However, the expected outcomes must go beyond the classic learning objectives and should include:
- Objectives aligned to the reaction to the online training
For instance, the program should obtain a 4.5/5 rating on relevancy from the learners.
- Objectives aligned to the new skill acquisition
For instance, the learners should score 80% on the quiz.
- Objectives aligned to the application of the acquired learning
For instance, with the new skill, there should be a 90% increase in the productivity.
- Objectives aligned to the business impact
For instance, with the new skill, there should be a 50% drop in the review time leading to a quicker completion of the project.
- Objectives aligned to the ROI
For instance, the training investment should get offset by reduced review costs over one year.
To fill the gap or aid the learner in picking up the required proficiency, the focus should now shift to the adoption of the right learning strategy. In the process, do look at establishing “learning as a continuum” and have an adequate blend of formal and informal learning.
Today, you are spoilt for choice on various immersive approaches that you can pick from and which can create “sticky learning” you desire. Notable among these are the following and when applied right they will help you meet your mandate.
- Scenarios (including decision-making, branching)
- Videos and interactive videos
Once the right learning strategy is in place, the focus shifts to the right assessment strategy:
- You can use assessments in interesting formats (for instance, using scenarios or gamified quizzes).
- You can also use informal learning approaches to push challenges (quizzes) that the learners can use to validate their knowledge or practice.
- The focus should be not only on the rating post the online training program but over an extended period to assess if the proficiency levels are being sustained and/or if you can push it to the next level.
Don’t depend on just one type of training (structured and formal). Provide a range of options that the learners can pick from. These should include:
- Informal learning
- Social learning
Both during the development of online training as well as post-deployment, opt for a Litmus test, that is, obtain the learner’s feedback and check for continuous improvement to maximize the gain.
You can use this feedback to determine:
- What is the learner’s reaction?
- If the training is helping them meet their mandate
- If the learning is effective and sticky
- Are the supporting aspects that can facilitate application of learning in place (Performance Support Tools or learning aids)?
- Is there a room for reinforcement and remediation?
- Is there a provision for constructive feedback to the learners on their performance?
To summarize, the task of determining ROI of online training is a complex one. I hope this article provides some practical insights and tips that you can use to create a positive impact on ROI. If you have any queries, do contact me at email@example.com.
6 Smart Approaches to Bring in Real-world Experiences in Online Training with Sc...
Introduction Scenario Based Learning is an absolute staple in online training. In this article, I share 6 approaches you can…
> Read Insight
8 Best Practices Business Leaders Can Adopt to Lead Through Business Disruption ...
Introduction As the world wades through the aftermath of the pandemic, with lockdowns and social distancing, the disruption is making…
> Read Insight
How to use Game-based Learning to Drive Learner Engagement and Motivation
When it comes to engaging and motivating remote learners, traditional learning approaches have their limitations. Game-based learning can foster greater…
> Read Insight