Home :: Insights :: How to Use Learning and Development Metrics to Measure Training Effectiveness and Impact

How to Use Learning and Development Metrics to Measure Training Effectiveness and Impact

November 4, 2020 | By Soma Bhaduri


How to Use Employee Training Metrics to Measure Training Effectiveness and Impact

Training metrics enable you to objectively assess the effectiveness of your learning solutions, feed training program improvements, and help drive business performance. Examine their significance and how you can use them to determine training effectiveness and, eventually, impact on business.

What Are Employee Training Metrics?

Employee Training Metrics are quantitative indicators designed to evaluate the effectiveness and impact of training programs within an organization, particularly in terms of how they align with and drive overall organizational goals and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). By focusing on these metrics, organizations can ensure their training programs are not only effective and relevant but also directly contribute to achieving broader organizational goals. These metrics provide a clear line of sight from training initiatives to key business outcomes, such as improved productivity, enhanced quality, increased customer satisfaction, and higher financial returns, thereby aligning training efforts with strategic objectives and overall organizational success.

Training solutions based on robust strategic foundations are inherently measurable. Examples of a few next-gen training metrics include:

  • Completion rate
  • Assessment success
  • Job function relevance
  • Behavior change rate
  • Impact on KPIs
  • Financial ROI

What are Learning and Development Metrics?

Learning and development measurements are how L&D groups measure the viability of their preparation and advancement programs. These metrices are quantitative indicators and are used to evaluate the effectiveness, efficiency, and impact of training programs within an organization. L&D metrics for a modern workforce in skill-based organizations can ensure training effectiveness, align learning initiatives with strategic goals, enhance workforce skills, and achieve significant returns on investment.

Outlined here are a few key L&D metrics:

  • Productivity of new hires: Efficient onboarding is crucial for the success of any company. New hires are not only expected to get acquainted with their roles, but also integrate into culture of the company and have the necessary resources to thrive. Learning and Development (L&D) teams play a pivotal role in this process by providing training programs, resources, and ongoing support to help new employees quickly integrate and become productive members of the team. Investing in effective onboarding through L&D initiatives can lead to higher employee satisfaction, retention, and overall performance, benefiting the company in the long run.
  • Employee retention: Measuring the impact of Learning and Development (L&D) programs on employee retention is a strategic approach. By comparing the retention rates of employees who have participated in learning programs with those who haven’t, you can gauge the effectiveness of your L&D initiatives. If the results show that employees who engage in the L&D programs are more likely to stay with the company, it provides a strong argument for the value of investing in such programs. Moreover, apart from measuring retention rates, it’s also advantageous to evaluate other factors such as job satisfaction, skill development, and career advancement opportunities provided by L&D initiatives.
  • Internal mobility: This metric measures the percentage of positions filled internally compared to those filled externally. A higher internal mobility rate indicates that employees are advancing within the organization, which can be a positive outcome of effective L&D programs.
  • Learning completion rates: Learning completion rates are a fundamental metric in Learning and Development (L&D) programs, indicating the effectiveness of training initiatives and employee engagement with learning materials. Completion rates can reveal whether the content is engaging, relevant, and valuable to employees. Higher completion rates suggest that the material resonates with learners and meets their needs. It’s important to note that while completion rates are valuable metrics, they should be analyzed in conjunction with other indicators, such as knowledge retention, skill acquisition, and on-the-job performance, to provide a comprehensive assessment of the impact of L&D initiatives.
  • Closing skill gaps: Closing skill gaps through Learning and Development (L&D) initiatives is essential for ensuring that employees have the knowledge and capabilities required to perform their roles effectively. By leveraging these L&D metrics, organizations can systematically track progress in closing skill gaps, identify areas for improvement, and optimize training strategies to ensure continuous skill development and alignment with business objectives.

In addition, the NexGen ROI model designed by EI incorporates specific performance metrics to align L&D strategy with business objectives. By offering a more nuanced and data-driven approach, this model helps customize learning initiatives according to the skills and competencies critical for achieving strategic business objectives.

Why Should You Identify and Use Learning and Development Metrics?

While there are several reasons, here are top 4 that you must consider:

  • Improving your organization for the future: Being aware of, and taking into consideration the standards of learning and development strategies enables to organization to boost performance while ensuring a healthy work environment, thus enabling the organization to have a
  • Measuring your business return on investment: L&D metrics make sure to give you access to specific information regarding which elements of training lead to substantial results and which ones can be improved.
  • Ensuring better alignment with business objectives: Considering that the implementing of L&D metrics implies being able to unambiguously gauge the efficiency of processes and its contribution to previously ordained objectives, it is of great assistance while ensuring a more cohesive alignment of business objectives and the measures applied to realize them.
  • Improving engagement and retention: Since the information of which aspects are leading to a return on investment and aspects require improvement is easily available, they can be leveraged to improve the quality of trainings and thereby the engagement and retention

What Is the Significance of Training Metrics in Assessing Learning Effectiveness?

Analyzing training metrics drives improvement. Often, organizations don’t factor how to measure the impact of training until after the solutions are implemented. Instead, training metrics should be identified in the Training Needs Analysis (TNA) phase.

Effective training metrics:

  • Will help you validate if the planned training is improving employee and business performance.
  • Can help you identify where employees struggle, feeding into the training design loop.
  • Can then be used to help drive business results as employee behavior improves.

Using the right training metrics offers several advantages for organizations:

  1. Enhanced Training Effectiveness: By accurately measuring training outcomes, organizations can ensure their programs are effective and meet learning objectives.
  2. Improved ROI on Training: Understanding the impact of training on performance and business goals helps in maximizing the return on investment in learning and development.
  3. Targeted Skill Development: Metrics help identify specific areas where employees need improvement, allowing for more focused and efficient training.
  4. Better Decision-Making: Data-driven insights from training metrics guide strategic decisions related to workforce development and resource allocation.
  5. Increased Employee Engagement: When training is relevant and effective, as evidenced by positive metrics, it can boost employee motivation and engagement.
  6. Facilitating Continuous Improvement: Ongoing assessment through metrics enables organizations to continually refine and enhance their training programs.

Evaluation Methodologies You Can Adopt to Measure Employee Training Effectiveness and Impact

There are several training metric models that you can pick from to measure training effectiveness and impact, such as Learning-Transfer Evaluation Model (LTEM), Kaufman’s Five Levels of Evaluation, Kirkpatrick’s Levels of Evaluation, and so on.  A number of organizations use one or more of these models, sometimes modifying them to fit their needs.

While this is a common approach, it has been observed that traditional evaluation using Kirkpatrick’s model from the 1950s and its enhancement by Phillips in the 1970s, are outdated and in often insufficient for aligning Learning and Development (L&D) strategies with business objectives. To address this gap, EI has developed the NexGen ROI model that:

  • Integrates advanced analytics, real-time data, and a holistic approach to ROI assessment.
  • Offers a detailed understanding of how learning initiatives directly contribute to organizational success
  • Provides insights particularly on dynamic workplaces that prioritize continuous skill development

The NexGen ROI model:

  • Aligns L&D strategies with strategic business goals
  • Incorporates specific performance metrics and data-driven insights
  • Enhances measurement of learning effectiveness with real-time feedback and advanced analytics
  • Redefines traditional assessment metrics
  • Provides a nuanced and adaptive framework
  • Demonstrates direct impact of skill development on overall business success

What Tips and Strategies Can Help You Identify the Right Employee Training Metrics for Your Training Program?

The list below outlines some useful strategies to identify the right training metrics:

  • Consult with key stakeholders – before development, on the metrics they care about. Make sure to use your L&D expertise to inform your collaboration.
  • Avoid using L&D jargon when collaborating with stakeholders – Modify your language to suit the audience.
  • Focus on objectively quantifiable metrics – Subjective ratings can be misleading and are difficult to validate.
  • Determine the value of measuring the effectiveness of a training program. It takes effort to evaluate training effectiveness, and those that support key strategic outcomes should be the focus of your training metrics.
  • Report honestly, even when faced with poor results – Accept and learn from failure.
  • Avoid highlighting low-level metrics, such as enrollment and completion rates.

12 Examples of Commonly Used Training Metrics and L&D Metrics

  1. Completion Rates: The percentage of employees who successfully complete the training program.
  2. Knowledge Retention: Measured through pre- and post-training assessments to evaluate how much information participants have retained.
  3. Skill Improvement: Assessed through practical tests or simulations to determine how effectively the training has improved specific skills.
  4. Behavioral Changes: Observing changes in employee behavior in the workplace that can be attributed to the training.
  5. Employee Engagement: Employee feedback and surveys post-training to assess their engagement and satisfaction with the training.
  6. Time to Proficiency: The time it takes for employees to become proficient in the skills taught in the training.
  7. Impact on Performance: Measuring the impact of training on individual or team performance metrics.
  8. Return on Investment (ROI): Calculating the financial return on investment from the training, considering costs vs. benefits.
  9. Application of Skills: Evaluating how effectively employees are applying new skills or knowledge in their day-to-day work.
  10. Training Cost per Employee: Calculating the total cost of training per participant.
  11. Employee Turnover Rates: Assessing whether the training has an impact on employee retention and turnover rates.
  12. Customer Satisfaction: If applicable, measuring changes in customer satisfaction levels as a result of improved employee performance following training.

Comprehensive Set of Training Metrics

  1. Learning and Development Metrics: This allows us to understand surface level and quantitative details regarding the training
    • FTE in L&D
    • Unique employees in L&D
    • Total participants
    • Unique participants
  2. Course and Content Utilization: This gives us more in-depth and substantial information about the efficacy of the courses that are made available to users as well as the ones that were particularly made use of.
    • Courses available
    • Courses used
    • Documents accessed
    • Documents available
    • Percentage of courses available by type of learning
    • Percentage of courses developed on time
    • Percentage of courses delivered on time
    • Total documents accessed
    • Unique users of content
    • Utilization rate
  3. Employee Engagement and Participation: This allows us to gauge the pulse of the learners as a collective, and gives us quantitative data regarding the various activities that the learner can indulge in
    • Active communities of practice
    • Active members in communities of practice
    • Percentage of employees reached by learning
    • Percentage of employees who have completed training on compliance and ethics
    • Percentage of employees who participate in formal learning
    • Percentage of employees who participate in informal learning
    • Percentage of employees with individual development plans
    • Percentage of employees using the learning portal
    • User satisfaction with communities of practice
  4. Performance and Competency: Enables us to have qualitative information on the ways learners navigate the courses and helps us flesh out the details on how they go about their learning journey.
    • Competency rating
    • Job performance
    • Workforce competency rate
    • Performance support tools available
    • Performance support tools used
    • Total performance support tools used
    • Unique performance support tool users
    • User satisfaction with performance support tools
  5. Learning Effectiveness: This allows us to gauge the efficiency of the effect of the learning material on the learners, in substantial ways and also the impact of them on the organization.
    • Application of learning
    • Impact
    • Results
    • Return on investment
  6. Cost and Budget Analysis: Gives us quantitative information on the variables of the organization to offer these trainings to their learners
    • Budget
    • Cost reduction
    • Total cost (organization)
  7. Completion Metrics: Gives us quantitative information on the timeline of learning and the number of learners that have seen the training through.
    • Completions
    • Completion date
    • Completion rate
  8. Customer and Stakeholder Satisfaction: Gives us qualitative information that allows us to realize what worked well and what requires improvement.
    • Objective owner satisfaction
    • Objective owner expectations met
    • User satisfaction with learning portal (or content)

How Should You Align Employee Training Metrics to KPIs?

Aligning employee training metrics with Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) is crucial for organizations to ensure that learning initiatives contribute directly to strategic objectives and drive business success. Here’s how to effectively align training metrics with KPIs:

  • Identify Strategic Objectives: Determine the overarching strategic goals and objectives of the organization that the training initiatives aim to support.
  • Define Relevant KPIs: Select Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that directly reflect the desired outcomes of the training programs and are aligned with the strategic objectives.
  • Map Training Metrics to KPIs: Establish a clear connection between the specific metrics used to evaluate employee training (e.g., completion rates, performance improvement) and the identified KPIs.
  • Establish Baselines and Targets: Set baseline measurements for both training metrics and KPIs to gauge current performance levels. Define target values for KPIs that represent the desired outcomes to be achieved through the training initiatives.
  • Regular Monitoring and Evaluation: Continuously monitor and evaluate both training metrics and KPIs to track progress, identify areas for improvement, and ensure alignment with strategic objectives. Adjust training programs as necessary to optimize performance and maximize impact on KPIs.

Parting Thoughts

By aligning employee training metrics with Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), organizations create a roadmap for measurable success. Through strategic alignment, clear mapping, and ongoing evaluation, training initiatives become directly linked to organizational goals. Leveraging advanced analytics and an integrated approach, such as the NexGen ROI model from EI, ensures that training investments yield tangible business outcomes. In embracing this alignment, organizations foster a culture of continuous improvement, driving both individual and organizational growth.

Related Insights